DBF-New-Vintage-Headerv4
HIGHEST RATED NEW TV SHOWS COLLECTION
Only new scripted TV Shows  |  NO Documentaries  | No Animated shows  |  No Reality TV
The Top 50 Highest Rated New TV Shows of 2019
The Top 25 Highest Rated New TV Shows of 2019

Here is a looked at the highest rated brand new scripted TV shows that debuted in 2019. We have taken a data-driven approach and used the scores from IMDb, Rotton Tomatoes and Metacritic and worked the average score for each show that debuted in 2019. Here are the top 50;

50 – Watchmen
Crime  |  Drama  |  Action & Adventure  |  Sci-Fi & Fantasy
20 October 2019  – ended  |  Limited Series  |  9 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.2 |  RT Users:  5.6  |  RT Critics:  9.6  |  Meteoritic Critics: 8.5  |  Metacritic Users: 5.6
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.50 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Watchmen is an American superhero drama limited series based on the 1986 DC Comics series of the same title, created by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons. The TV series was created for HBO by Damon Lindelof.

The show takes place in 2019 Tulsa, Oklahoma. A white supremacist group, the Seventh Kavalry, inspired by Rorschach’s writings and masked image, wages violent war against minorities and the police that enforce special reparations for victims of racial injustice. On Christmas Eve 2016, during an event that came to be known as the “White Night”, the Kavalry attacked the homes of 40 police officers working for the Tulsa Police Department.[1] Of those who survived, only two stayed with the force: Detective Angela Abar and Police Chief Judd Crawford.[2] As the police force was rebuilt, laws were passed that required police to not disclose their profession and to protect their identities while on the job by wearing masks, which included allowing for costumed police officers. As Crawford’s police force attempts to crack down on the Seventh Kavalry, Abar finds herself at the center of two competing plots to kidnap Doctor Manhattan, who has been working with Hooded Justice, the original masked hero and survivor of the Tulsa massacre.

49 – Sanditon
Drama
25 August 2019  – ongoing  |  2 Seasons so far  |  14 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.7 |  RT Users:  8.9  |  RT Critics:  7.3  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.9  |  Metacritic Users: 6.7
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.50 /10
SYNOPSIS:
Sanditon is a British historical drama television series adapted by Andrew Davies from an unfinished manuscript by Jane Austen and starring Rose Williams, Theo James, and Ben Lloyd-Hughes. Set during the Regency era, the plot follows a young and naive heroine as she navigates the new seaside resort of Sanditon.
48 – Swamp Thing
Mystery  |  Sci-Fi & Fantasy  |  Drama
31 May 2019  – cancelled  |  1 Season  |  10 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.4 |  RT Users:  7.3  |  RT Critics:  9.2  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.9  |  Metacritic Users: 6.8
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.52 /10
SYNOPSIS:
Swamp Thing is an American superhero horror television series created by Gary Dauberman and Mark Verheiden for DC Universe, based on the DC Comics character of the same name. Abby Arcane returns home to Marais, Louisiana, to investigate a deadly swamp-borne virus, where she develops a bond with disgraced scientist Alec Holland. After Holland tragically dies, Abby discovers the mysteries of the swamp and that Holland might not be dead after all.
47 – After Life
Comedy  |  Drama
8 March 2019  – ended  |  3 Seasons  |  18 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.4  |  RT Users:  8.6  |  RT Critics:  7.0  |  Meteoritic Critics: 5.7  |  Metacritic Users: 7.9
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.52 /10
SYNOPSIS:
After Life is a British black comedy-drama streaming television series created, written, produced, and directed by Ricky Gervais, who plays lead character Tony Johnson.Set in the fictional town of Tambury, After Life follows newspaper writer Tony Johnson, whose life is turned upside down after his wife dies from breast cancer. He contemplates suicide, but instead decides to spend his life punishing the world for his wife’s death by saying and doing whatever he wants regardless of how it makes other people feel. Although he thinks of this as his “superpower”, his plan is undermined when everyone around him pities him and tries to make him a better person.
46 – Good Trouble
Drama
8 January 2019  – ongoing  |  4 Seasons  |  68 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.5  |  RT Users:  5.6  |  RT Critics:  n/a  |  Meteoritic Critics: 8.3  |  Metacritic Users: 8.7
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.53 /10
SYNOPSIS:
Good Trouble is an American drama television series. It is a spin-off of the Freeform show The Fosters. Taking place a few years after the events of The Fosters, Adams Foster siblings Callie and Mariana relocate to Los Angeles to begin the next phase of their lives. As they move into a communal living apartment building called The Coterie, Callie becomes a law clerk working for Judge Wilson while Mariana becomes a software engineer. The two of them navigate their young adult lives while interacting with their neighbors and the people they befriend.
45 – City on a Hill
Crime  |  Drama
16 June 2019  – Ongoing  |  3 Seasons so far
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.5  |  RT Users:  8.1  |  RT Critics:  8.8  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.5  |  Metacritic Users: 6.8
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.54 /10
SYNOPSIS:
In early 90s Boston, an African-American District Attorney comes in from Brooklyn advocating change and forms an unlikely alliance with a corrupt yet venerated FBI veteran invested in maintaining the status quo. Together they take on a family of armored car robbers from Charlestown in a case that grows to encompass and eventually upend Boston’s city-wide criminal justice system.
44 – The Umbrella Academy
Action & Adventure  |  Sci-Fi & Fantasy  |  Drama
15 February 2019  –  Ongoing  |  3 Seasons  |  30 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.9  |  RT Users:  7.6  |  RT Critics:  8.6  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.4  |  Metacritic Users: 7.3
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.56 /10
SYNOPSIS:

The Umbrella Academy is an American superhero streaming television series based on the comic book series of the same name written by Gerard Way, illustrated by Gabriel Bá, and published by Dark Horse Comics.

The Umbrella Academy is set in a universe where 43 women around the world give birth simultaneously at noon on October 1, 1989, although none had shown any sign of pregnancy until labor began. Seven of the children are adopted by eccentric billionaire Sir Reginald Hargreeves and turned into a superhero team that he calls “The Umbrella Academy.” Hargreeves gives the children numbers rather than names, but their robot-mother, Grace, later names six of them: Luther, Diego, Allison, Klaus, Ben, and Vanya. Reginald puts six of the children to work fighting crime but keeps Vanya apart from her siblings’ activities, claiming she demonstrates no powers of her own.

43 – Dead Pixels
Comedy
28 March 2019  –  Ongoing  |  2 Seasons  |  12 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.4  |  RT Users:  7.3  |  RT Critics:  9.0  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.6  |  Metacritic Users: 7.6
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.58 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Dead Pixels focuses on the obsession of three friends, Meg, Nicky and Usman, for a fictional massive multiplayer online role-playing game (MMORPG) called Kingdom Scrolls.

Meg, Nicky and Usman’s lives all revolve around their obsession for the massively popular fantasy game “Kingdom Scrolls” – a mystical, magical and most importantly virtual world of wizards and wyverns. But when gaming n00b Russell bumbles into their team, the group find themselves increasingly forced to deal with the real world.

42 – Servant
Drama
28 November 2019  –  Ongoing  |  3 Seasons  |  30 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.5  |  RT Users:  7.5  |  RT Critics:  8.8  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.8  |  Metacritic Users: 7.5
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.62 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Servant is an American psychological horror streaming television series created by Tony Basgallop and executive produced alongside M. Night Shyamalan, who serves as showrunner.

A wealthy Philadelphia couple, Dorothy and Sean Turner, experience a fracture in their marriage after the death of their thirteen-week-old son, Jericho. The couple undergo transitory object therapy using a lifelike reborn doll after Dorothy experiences a full psychotic break. The doll, which Dorothy believes is her real child, was the only thing that brought her out of a catatonic state following Jericho’s death. Six weeks after his death, they hire a young nanny, Leanne Grayson, to move in and take care of Jericho, the reborn doll, opening their home to a “mysterious force”.

41 – Doom Patrol
Sci-Fi & Fantasy  |  Drama
15 February 2019  –  Ongoing  |  3 Seasons so far
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.8  |  RT Users:  7.6  |  RT Critics:  9.7  |  Meteoritic Critics: 7.0  |  Metacritic Users: 6.4
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.70 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Doom Patrol is based on the DC Comics superhero team of the same name, the series features Jane (Diane Guerrero), Rita Farr (April Bowlby), Vic Stone (Joivan Wade), Larry Trainor (Matt Bomer / Matthew Zuk), Cliff Steele (Brendan Fraser / Riley Shanahan), and Chief (Timothy Dalton) as the members of the eponymous Doom Patrol.

Doom Patrol follows the unlikely heroes of the eponymous team who all received their powers through tragic circumstances and are generally shunned by society. Most members of the team were treated by the Chief, a medical doctor who gave them residence in his mansion to help protect them from the outside world. Their name derives from an earlier Doom Patrol team that was formed by the Chief.

40 – His Dark Materials
Sci-Fi & Fantasy  |  Drama
3 November 2019  – Ongoing  |  2 Seasons so far
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.8  |  RT Users:  8.4  |  RT Critics:  8.1  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.9  |  Metacritic Users: 7.5
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.74 /10
SYNOPSIS:
Lyra is an orphan who lives in a parallel universe in which science, theology and magic are entwined. Her search for a kidnapped friend uncovers a sinister plot involving stolen children, and turns into a quest to understand a mysterious phenomenon called Dust. She is later joined on her journey by Will, a boy who possesses a knife that can cut windows between worlds. As she learns the truth about her parents and her prophesied destiny, the two young people are caught up in a war against celestial powers that ranges across many worlds.
39 – Stumptown
Drama
25 September 2019   –  cancelled  |  1 Season  |  18 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.5  |  RT Users:  8.3  |  RT Critics:  9.3  |  Meteoritic Critics: 7.3  |  Metacritic Users: 6.3
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.74 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Stumptown is based on the comic book series of the same name, created by Greg Rucka, Matthew Southworth and Justin Greenwood.

Dex Parios (Cobie Smulders) is a sharp-witted military veteran, who struggles to get by and take care of her younger brother Ansel (Cole Sibus), in Portland, Oregon. She also struggles with PTSD from her time as a Marine in Afghanistan, where she worked in military intelligence until she was injured by an explosion which killed her college sweetheart and former lover. Burdened by heavy gambling debts and unable to hold down a steady job, she becomes a private investigator to solve problems where the police cannot get involved. Detective Miles Hoffman (Michael Ealy) refers problems to her, and Grey McConnell (Jake Johnson), a bar owner and Dex’s closest friend, provides moral support and employs her brother Ansel at his bar.

38 – Why Women Kill
Comedy  |  Crime  |  Drama
15 August 2019  (Cancelled)  |  2 Seasons
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.3  |  RT Users:  9.0  |  RT Critics:  7.6  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.2  |  Metacritic Users: 7.9
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.80 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Why Women Kill is set in multiple time periods, the series depicts the events leading to deaths caused by women.

The first season of Why Women Kill follows three women from different decades who are connected through having all lived in the same Pasadena mansion and experiencing infidelity in their marriages. Beth Ann Stanton remains content as a housewife in 1963 until she learns of her husband Rob’s unfaithfulness; socialite Simone Grove discovers her third husband Karl’s homosexuality and begins her own affair with a younger man in 1984; and in 2019, bisexual attorney Taylor Harding finds her open marriage tested when she and her husband Eli become attracted to the same woman, Jade. The infidelity in each marriage sets off a chain of events that ends with a death caused by a woman.

37 – Evil
Drama
26 September 2019   –  Ongoing  |  3 Seasons  | 36 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.7  |  RT Users:  8.3  |  RT Critics:  9.5  |  Meteoritic Critics: 8.2  |  Metacritic Users: 5.5
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.84 /10
SYNOPSIS:
Evil is an American supernatural drama and features an ensemble cast led by Katja Herbers, Mike Colter, and Aasif Mandvi. A skeptical forensic psychologist (Herbers) allies with a Catholic seminarian (Colter) and a technology contractor (Mandvi) to investigate purported supernatural incidents.
36 – Special
Comedy
12 April 2019  –  ended  |  2 Seasons | 16 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.6  |  RT Users:  8.5  |  RT Critics:  9.8  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.7  |  Metacritic Users: 6.7
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.86 /10
SYNOPSIS:
Special stars Ryan O’Connell and is a semi-autobiographical account of his life as a gay man with cerebral palsy pursuing new friendships, relationships, and self-sufficiency. It is based on O’Connell’s memoir I’m Special: And Other Lies We Tell Ourselves.
35 – For All Mankind
Drama  |  Sci-Fi & Fantasy  |  War & Politics
1 November 2019   –  Ongoing  |  3 Seasons  |  30 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.0  |  RT Users:  8.1  |  RT Critics:  9.0  |  Meteoritic Critics: 7.3  |  Metacritic Users: 7.1
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.90 /10
SYNOPSIS:

For All Mankind is an American science fiction drama television series created and written by Ronald D. Moore, of Battlestar Galactica fame.

In an alternate timeline in 1969, Soviet cosmonaut Alexei Leonov becomes the first human to land on the Moon. This outcome devastates morale at NASA, but also catalyzes an American effort to catch up. With the Soviet Union emphasizing diversity by including a woman in subsequent landings, the United States is forced to match pace, training women and minorities who were largely excluded from the initial decades of U.S. space exploration. Each subsequent season takes place ten years later, with season 2 taking place in the 1980s, season 3 taking place in the 1990s, (and as revealed in the season 3 finale) season 4 taking place in the 2000s.

34 – Criminal: UK
Crime  |  Drama
20 September 2019   –  ended  |  2 Seasons  |  7 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.6  |  RT Users:  9.0  |  RT Critics:  9.2  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.5  |  Metacritic Users: 7.3
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.92 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Criminal: UK is a British police procedural anthology series created by George Kay and Jim Field Smith, starring Katherine Kelly, Lee Ingleby, Mark Stanley, Rochenda Sandall and Shubham Saraf as the highly-trained members of a special interrogative division of the Metropolitan Police.

The show is set within the confines of a police interrogation room (and its viewing quarters) where a specialised interrogative unit of the Metropolitan Police engage in intense games of psychological cat-and-mouse with their suspects to find the answers that they need to close the case.

33 – The Righteous Gemstones
Comedy
18 August 2019  –  Ongoing  |  2 Seasons  |  18 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.1  |  RT Users:  8.5  |  RT Critics:  8.2  |  Meteoritic Critics: 7.2  |  Metacritic Users: 7.7
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.94 /10
SYNOPSIS:

The Righteous Gemstones is an American television series created by Danny McBride. It stars McBride, John Goodman, Edi Patterson, Adam DeVine, Cassidy Freeman, Tony Cavalero, Tim Baltz, Skyler Gisondo, and Walton Goggins.

The Righteous Gemstones depicts a family of televangelists and megachurch pastors led by widowed patriarch Eli Gemstone (John Goodman). Eli and his immature children, Jesse (Danny McBride), Judy (Edi Patterson) and Kelvin (Adam DeVine), lead opulent lives funded by church donations.

In the first season, Eli’s estranged brother-in-law, Baby Billy Freeman (Walton Goggins), is brought in to lead the Gemstones’ new shopping-mall-based satellite church, which leads to a conflict with Rev. John Wesley Seasons (Dermot Mulroney) whose smaller, neighboring church is threatened. Concurrently, a trio of masked figures blackmail Jesse with a scandalous video documenting the lewd behavior of him and his best friends.

32 – Wu-Tang: An American Saga
Drama
4 September 2019   –  Ongoing  |  2 Seasons  |  20 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.3  |  RT Users:  9.5  |  RT Critics:  7.4  |  Meteoritic Critics: 5.8  |  Metacritic Users: 8.7
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.94 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Wu-Tang: An American Saga is an American drama streaming television series, created by RZA and Alex Tse. 

Wu-Tang: An American Saga is set in New York City during the height of the crack cocaine epidemic in the early 1990s. It follows the Wu-Tang Clan’s formation, a vision of Bobby Diggs aka The RZA (Sanders), and rise amid the dangers and excesses that came with the epidemic. Seeking his own way out, Diggs turns to rap in order to carve a path to fame going against his older brother Divine (Martinez), who favored the drug trade as the means to giving their family a better life. The story depicts how it all came together for the clan as Diggs unites a dozen young black men who are torn between music and crime. The group battles against the forces that hold them down and these include their own occasional impulse to give up the fight

31 – Good Omens
Sci-Fi & Fantasy  |  Comedy  |  Drama
30 May 2019   –  Ongoing  |  1 Season | 6 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.0  |  RT Users:  9.0  |  RT Critics:  8.4  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.6  |  Metacritic Users: 7.7
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.94 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Good Omens is a fantasy comedy series created and written by Neil Gaiman, based on his and Terry Pratchett’s 1990 novel of the same name.

Michael Sheen and David Tennant lead a large ensemble cast that also includes Adria Arjona, Miranda Richardson, Michael McKean, Jack Whitehall, Nick Offerman, Brian Cox, Mireille Enos, Jon Hamm, and Frances McDormand as the voice of God, who narrates the series.

Set in 2018, the series follows the demon Crowley (David Tennant) and the angel Aziraphale (Michael Sheen), longtime acquaintances who, having grown accustomed to life on Earth as representatives of Heaven and Hell, seek to prevent the coming of the Antichrist and with it Armageddon, the final battle between Heaven and Hell.

30 – Godfather of Harlem
Crime  |  Drama
29 September 2019   –  Ongoing  |  2 Seasons so far   | 20 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.0  |  RT Users:  8.5  |  RT Critics:  9.2  |  Meteoritic Critics: 7.2  |  Metacritic Users: 6.9
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.96 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Godfather of Harlem is written by Chris Brancato and Paul Eckstein, and stars Forest Whitaker as 1960s New York City gangster Bumpy Johnson.

Godfather of Harlem tells the true story of infamous crime boss Bumpy Johnson, who in the early 1960s returned from ten years in prison to find the neighborhood he once ruled in shambles. With the streets controlled by the Italian mob, Bumpy must take on the Genovese crime family to regain control. During the brutal battle, he forms an alliance with Muslim minister Malcolm X – catching Malcolm’s political rise in the crosshairs of social upheaval and a mob war that threatens to tear the city apart.

29 – Jett
Drama  |  Crime
14 June 2019  –  cancelled  |  1 Season   |  9 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.4  |  RT Users:  8.9  |  RT Critics:  9.4  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.5  |  Metacritic Users: 7.6
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
7.96 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Jett is an American action crime drama television series created by Sebastian Gutierrez. It stars Carla Gugino.

Jett begins when “fresh out of prison, world-class thief Daisy “Jett” Kowalski is forced back into doing what she does best by dangerous and eccentric criminals determined to exploit her skills for their own ends.”

28 – Dickinson
Comedy  |  Drama
1 November 2019  –  ended  |  3 Seasons   |  30 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.6  |  RT Users:  9.2  |  RT Critics:  9.2  |  Meteoritic Critics: 7.2  |  Metacritic Users: 6.9
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
8.02 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Dickinson is an American comedy-drama television series about Emily Dickinson, created by Alena Smith and produced for Apple TV+. Starring Hailee Steinfeld as Emily Dickinson.

Dickinson takes place “during Emily Dickinson’s era with a modern sensibility and tone. It takes viewers into the world of Emily, audaciously exploring the constraints of society, gender, and family from the perspective of a budding writer who doesn’t fit in to her own time through her imaginative point of view. Dickinson is Emily’s coming-of-age story – one woman’s fight to get her voice heard.”

27 – Dead to Me
Drama  |  Mystery  |  Crime
3 May 2019   –  Ongoing  |  2 Seasons so far  |  10 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.0  |  RT Users:  8.9  |  RT Critics:  9.0  |  Meteoritic Critics: 6.8  |  Metacritic Users: 7.8
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
8.10 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Dead to Me is an American black comedy television series created by Liz Feldman and executively produced by Feldman, Will Ferrell, Adam McKay, and Jessica Elbaum. It stars Christina Applegate and Linda Cardellini as two grieving women who bond during therapy.

Dead to Me is about a friendship that blossoms between Jen (Applegate) and Judy (Cardellini). Jen is a recently widowed real estate agent based in Laguna Beach, California, trying to come to terms with her loss through therapy, exercise, and other methods. She uses anger and resentment as an outlet for her grief. She meets Judy in a grief support group. Jen mourns her husband, who was killed by a hit-and-run driver, while Judy claims she is grieving for her fiancé who died of a heart attack. In actuality, Judy is the hit-and-run driver and her fiancé broke up with her.

26 – Euphoria
Drama  |  Crime
16 June 2019   –  Ongoing  |  2 Seasons so far  |  16 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  8.4  |  RT Users:  8.4  |  RT Critics:  8.8  |  Meteoritic Critics: 7.0  |  Metacritic Users: 8.0
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
8.12 /10
SYNOPSIS:

Euphoria is an American teen drama television series created and principally written by Sam Levinson for HBO and based on the Israeli miniseries of the same name.

The series’ main character is Rue Bennett (Zendaya), a recovering teenage drug addict who struggles to find her place in the world.

Teenagers in the fictional town of East Highland seek hope while balancing the strains of love, loss, and addiction. Topics such as child abuse, drug abuse, toxic relationships, toxic positivity, hookup culture, social media, mental illness, codependency, infidelity, relapsing, repressed homosexuality, sobriety, human trafficking, domestic violence, and grief are explored.

25 – The Act
Drama  |  Crime
20 March 2019   –  Ended  |  1 Season  |  8 Eps
NETWORK:
IMDb:  7.9  |  RT Users:  9.1  |  RT Critics:  8.8  |  Meteoritic Critics: 7.3  |  Metacritic Users: 7.7
COMBINED SCORE:
Star icon
8.16 /10
SYNOPSIS:
The Act is an American true crime drama limited series that premiered in eight parts on March 20, 2019, on Hulu. The plot is based on the life of Gypsy Rose Blanchard and the murder of her mother, Dee Dee Blanchard, who was accused of abusing her daughter by fabricating illness and disabilities as a direct consequence of Munchausen syndrome by proxy. Joey King portrayed Gypsy, while Patricia Arquette played her mother, Dee Dee Blanchard. AnnaSophia Robb, Chloë Sevigny, and Calum Worthy star in supporting roles.